Jones - Participatory budgeting for culture: handing power to communities?
Jones, P. (2019) Participatory budgeting for culture: handing power to communities? In Phil Jones, Beth Perry, and Paul Long (eds), Cultural Intermediaries Connecting Communities: Revisiting Approaches to Cultural Engagement (Bristol, 2019; online edn, Policy Press Scholarship Online, 23 Jan. 2020)
The concept of participatory budgeting was developed as a means of bypassing corrupt local elites and creating better governance in developing countries. Applied in the global north, it attempts to give power back to communities to set spending priorities within their neighbourhoods. This chapter examines two attempts at participatory budgeting for the arts in Birmingham – the city council’s Arts Champions scheme and a participatory action research project led by the author. Two key problems highlighted by the case studies are identified. First, funders being reluctant to hand full control to neighbourhoods over how spending is undertaken, with a tendency to push communities toward the funders’ spending priorities. Second, and related to this, is a lack of capacity at neighbourhood level to move beyond the “ideas generation” stage, toward having the confidence to design and commission cultural projects to realise those ideas. This speaks to wider problems in deprived communities – notably education, skills and confidence – that cannot be tackled simply by adding cultural activity.
Phil Jones “Participatory budgeting for culture: handing power to communities?”